• We are open, and taking new patients & walk-ins. • Televisits are available for your safety & convenience. • We provide comprehensive primary care services. • Please bring your medications bottles during each visits.

How to Choose a Primary Care Doctor: A Guide

From healing fractures to overseeing preventive healthcare, the primary care physician (PCP) stands as a cornerstone in our contemporary healthcare system. Serving as the initial touchpoint when health concerns arise, the PCP plays a crucial role in offering preliminary diagnoses and delivering comprehensive care for individuals and entire families. 

Over the course of years or even decades, primary care physicians evolve into empathetic advocates and reliable health advisors, building lasting relationships with their patients.

So, when it comes to choosing a PCP, you’ll want to make an informed choice so that you receive personalized and comprehensive care.

What is a Primary Care Physician? 

A Primary Care Physician (PCP) serves as a fundamental healthcare anchor, acting as a central point for individuals in managing their health. Responsible for addressing routine health concerns, offering guidance on health-related queries, and delivering consistent care across different life stages, the primary care doctor serves as a trusted and long-term healthcare partner. Additionally, they play a pivotal role in coordinating specialized care by providing referrals to specialists when necessary.

Primary care physicians offer a wide range of general healthcare services, including:

  • Preventive care
  • Long-term health management
  • Regular checkups and screenings

They are adept at treating both acute and chronic illnesses, providing fundamental diagnoses and treatments. Moreover, they play a crucial role in health maintenance, patient education, disease prevention, and counseling, as outlined by the American Academy of Family Physicians

The bottom line is that PCPs take a comprehensive approach to ensure that patients receive holistic and personalized care across various healthcare settings.

Steps to Finding and Choosing a Primary Care Physician

If you're in search of a new Primary Care Physician (PCP), we've outlined an easy process to guide you through the selection. 

Step 1: Choose a Primary Care Specialty

Primary care physicians come in various categories, defined by the patients they serve and their chosen areas of expertise. Here are some key types:

Family Practice Physicians

  • Treat patients of all ages, offering comprehensive care.
  • Aligned with the definition of primary care, providing first-contact, continuous, comprehensive, and coordinated care to diverse populations.

Internal Medicine Doctors (Internists)

  • Specialize in treating adults and focus on internal organ-related conditions.
  • Some may specialize further in subspecialties like infectious disease, immunology, or oncology.


  • Primary care physicians specializing in the care of children, covering physical, behavioral, and mental aspects.
  • Can also specialize in subspecialties such as pediatric immunology, cardiology, or adolescent health.

Other Categories Include:

  • General Practitioners: Offer general care for patients of all ages.
  • OB-GYN (Obstetrics and Gynecology): Focus on women's reproductive health.
  • Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants: Provide primary care services with varying levels of autonomy.
  • Geriatricians: Specialize in the care of seniors.

Understanding these categories helps individuals make informed choices when selecting a primary care physician customized to their health needs and demographics.

Note: The mentioned specialties are considered part of primary care. If you have a condition that goes beyond the scope of general care, your doctor might recommend consulting a specialist with expertise in treating your particular condition.

Step 2: Create a List of Potential Doctors 

After deciding on the kind of primary care physician you prefer, begin your search for the right doctor. Identify a handful of primary care doctors associated with your insurance, whether they are in-network for your plan or out-of-network, and compile them into a shortlist.

Here are some factors to consider:

  • Office Hours: Check if the provider offers flexible hours, including weekends or evenings, to accommodate your schedule and minimize the need to take time off work.
  • Office Location: Consider the convenience of the location. Choose a primary care physician close to your home, office, or another preferred location. Factor in aspects like parking and traffic, as you may develop a long-term relationship with your PCP and visit frequently, especially for a large family.
  • Days and Location: Verify the doctor's practice days in a specific location, as some doctors may work in multiple offices throughout the week. This information may not always be available on the provider's insurance profile.
  • Insurance Affiliation: Contact the provider's office to confirm that they accept your insurance plan.
  • Accepts New Patients: Ensure the doctor is currently accepting new patients.
  • Appointments Availability: Check the availability of appointments. Popular doctors may have bookings months in advance.
  • Telemedicine: Inquire whether the office is equipped for telemedicine in case you cannot make an in-person visit due to health concerns.

Step 3: Seek Recommendations

Apart from exploring doctors through your insurance provider, seek recommendations from reliable friends or family members.


Ask trusted local friends, family, and co-workers to suggest PCPs they appreciate. If your current doctor is retiring or relocating, inquire if they can provide a referral.

Online Reviews

While online reviews can offer insights into aspects like staff friendliness and wait times, they may not be reliable indicators of a doctor's expertise or experience with specific conditions. Be cautious, as online reviews can sometimes be fraudulent. Consider them, but don't heavily rely on them for decision-making. At this point, you likely have a shortlist of doctors for potential consideration.

Step 4: Verify Hospital Affiliation 

Before finalizing your choice, check if the doctor is associated with your preferred hospital. Confirm whether your insurance includes coverage for admissions to this specific hospital. If you have a particular hospital preference, make sure the chosen doctor is affiliated with that facility.

Step 5: Consider Your Unique Preferences

While our previous recommendations are generally applicable, you may have specific preferences for your primary care physician. Before making a decision, jot down aspects you find crucial in the patient-doctor experience. Here are some factors to ponder:

  • Experience: Does the doctor have relevant experience in treating your existing health conditions?
  • Practice Type: Do you prefer an individual practitioner or a group practice? Some patients appreciate group practices for easy access to another doctor if the primary one is unavailable.
  • On-Site Facilities: Check if the practice offers on-site laboratories or x-rays if you prefer the convenience of having tests done at the same location.
  • Language: Ensure the doctor speaks your preferred language.
  • Gender Preference: Some individuals may have a preference for a specific gender.
  • Years in Practice: Consider the duration of the doctor's practice; some patients prefer more experienced practitioners.

Review each criterion on your list and confirm that each doctor aligns with your specified preferences. If not, consider narrowing down your list accordingly.

Step 6: Confirm Doctor's Background 

With your list now narrowed down to two or three doctors, it's crucial to verify their background and credentials if this is a priority for you. While most practicing doctors have clean records, it's prudent to ensure everything aligns with your expectations. If you want to verify credentials or are concerned about the rare possibility of medical negligence, follow these steps:

Credential Verification

Contact the medical board in your state to confirm the doctor's credentials and ensure they are in good standing.

Disciplinary Record Check

Inquire with the medical board about any disciplinary actions against the doctor, such as convictions, suspensions, or instances of medical negligence. This information helps ensure the doctor's professional integrity.

By taking these steps, you can have added confidence in your choice of a primary care physician.

Step 7: Prepare for Your Doctor Visit

As you schedule an appointment with your chosen primary care physician, the evaluation process extends through the stages before, during, and after your visit.

Assess Your Experience During the Visit

Congratulations on taking proactive steps for your health! Arriving at your appointment with your prepared list, continue the evaluation process during your visit. Take note of the following:

  • Comfort Level: Evaluate your comfort with the facilities and staff.
  • Trust: Consider if you feel confident in entrusting your doctor with your healthcare management.
  • Ease of Communication: Assess if you feel at ease communicating with your doctor.
  • Alignment on Treatment and Lifestyle Choices: Ensure you and your doctor agree on treatment options and lifestyle choices.
  • Questioning Comfort: Reflect on whether you feel comfortable asking questions.

Each primary care physician has a unique personality and communication style. While respect and integrity are expected, the best PCPs generally are:

  • Receptive listeners
  • Comfortable with patient autonomy 
  • Detailed-oriented
  • Empathetic and humble

Step 8: Trust Your Instincts

Following your doctor’s visit, reflect on your overall experience. Review your notes and consider the following:

  • Were your questions adequately addressed?
  • Can you easily seek clarification if needed?
  • Did you feel at ease and trust the physician?

If your answers are affirmative, it suggests a positive visit, and you may consider continuing with this doctor. However, if anything feels uneasy or unclear, trust your instincts.

Additional Tip: Seek a Second Opinion, if Necessary

If your visit left you less than fully satisfied, it's perfectly acceptable to seek a second opinion. Revisit your original list of doctors and consider the next one on your list. Your health is a priority, and finding the right primary care physician is crucial for your well-being.

Wrapping Up

Selecting a primary care physician is a decision that numerous individuals will encounter in their lifetime. Your primary care physician is a vital, long-term member of your extended family and a trusted health advisor. Finding a physician you can trust and feel comfortable with is crucial for a lasting and effective healthcare relationship. Approach the decision-making process with care; consider consulting more than one doctor if needed. Seek a physician whom you can rely on, someone who will act as a caring advocate for the health of both you and your family.

Find a Primary Care Physician at Indus Medical Associates

Ensure your well-being with a primary care physician at Indus Medical Associates. Trust our expert professionals to provide personalized and comprehensive healthcare. Take the first step towards a healthier future. Schedule your appointment now.